Exercise intolerance in chronic heart failure is not associated with impaired recovery of muscle function or submaximal exercise performance
MH Yamani,
P Sahgal,
L Wells,
and
BM Massie
Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, USA.
OBJECTIVES. This study investigated whether recovery of skeletal muscle function is impaired in patients with heart failure and whether impaired recovery is associated with abnormal submaximal systemic exercise tolerance during repeated testing. BACKGROUND. Patients with heart failure experience fatigue during daily activities. Because abnormalities of skeletal muscle play a role in their exercise intolerance, these symptoms may reflect a delay in muscle recovery and a resulting limitation in submaximal exercise tolerance. METHODS. Two protocols were used. In protocol 1, knee extensor strength and endurance, and their recovery after fatiguing exercise, were evaluated in 11 patients (mean [+/- SEM] age 62 +/- 5 years, New York Heart Association functional class 2.3 +/- 0.2, ejection fraction 24 +/- 5%) and in 10 age-matched sedentary control subjects. Protocol 2 examined the recovery of knee extensor endurance and submaximal exercise tolerance, as quantified on a self-powered treadmill, over 24 h in 18 patients (mean age 65 +/- 3 years, functional class 2.4 +/- 0.2, ejection fraction 23 +/- 3%) and in 10 control subjects. RESULTS. Peak oxygen consumption was reduced in both heart failure groups (15.4 +/- 1.4 and 15.6 +/- 1.0 ml/kg per min) compared with that in the respective control groups (23.1 +/- 2.9 and 25.6 +/- 1.0 ml/kg per min, both p < 0.05), as was muscle endurance but not muscle strength. In protocol 1, knee extensor endurance recovered more slowly in the patients than in control subjects (to 62 +/- 4% and 87 +/- 7% of the baseline value after 5 min, respectively, p < 0.05). In protocol 2, submaximal exercise tolerance was lower in the patients with heart failure than in control subjects (1,075 +/- 116 vs. 1,390 +/- 110 m), but knee extensor endurance and walking distance recovered fully by 10 and 30 min, respectively. CONCLUSIONS. Although these findings confirm earlier studies that demonstrated impaired muscle endurance in patients with heart failure, the results provide no evidence that recovery of either muscle function or submaximal exercise tolerance is delayed beyond the initial 5 to 10 min after exercise.
